19 KiB
| phase | verified | status | score | human_verification | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 07-engagement-overview-new | 2026-05-04T12:00:00Z | human_needed | 5/5 must-haves verified |
|
Phase 7: Engagement Overview (NEW) Verification Report
Phase Goal: A manager reaches Engagement from the More drawer and sees a phone-first overview — period chips, stacked summary cards, a sortable per-employee list, and one compact sparkline. Verified: 2026-05-04T12:00:00Z Status: human_needed Re-verification: No — initial verification
Execution Incident (Recorded for Transparency)
Wave 2 worktree-base recovery: The first attempted merge of Wave 2's executor worktree would have deleted multiple prior-phase files. Investigation revealed the worktree branch was created from a stale base. Resolution: orchestrator cherry-picked the 7 new Engagement* component files into the parent branch via a recovery commit (d637892). All 7 components verified present; all prior-phase files intact (21 components total in components/mobile/). TypeScript exits 0.
This incident does NOT affect the verdict — the recovered state is identical to what an in-place merge would have produced.
Documented Deviations (Pre-approved)
- Period chips (ENG-02): Roadmap SC-2 specifies "today / 7d / 30d" but data layer only supports D7/D30/D90. Phase 7 uses
7d / 30d / 90dchips (CONTEXT.md D-07). "Today" deferred to a future phase that adds D1 sync. - EngagementSortKey casing: Plan templates used
'Hours'|'Name'|'Utilization'but component exports'hours'|'name'|'utilization'(lowercase). The page'sSORT_TO_APImap uses matching lowercase keys. Display labels are correctly capitalized in the chip UI. - Page H1 typography: Uses
text-sm font-semibold(nottext-base) per UI-SPEC fix to keep declared font sizes at 4. - Inherited security gap on
/api/engagement/users: Existing endpoint lacks explicitrequireAuth(). Not made worse by Phase 7; documented for STATE.md follow-up.
Goal Achievement
Observable Truths
| # | Truth | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | More drawer links to /mobile/engagement; Engagement is NOT on the bottom nav (ENG-09) |
VERIFIED | MoreDrawer.tsx:37 has { href: '/mobile/engagement', label: 'Engagement', icon: Users }. BottomNav.tsx has 0 occurrences of "Engagement"/"engagement". |
| 2 | Page shows sticky 3-chip period selector (7d/30d/90d, default 30d) with active state | VERIFIED | EngagementPeriodChips.tsx has sticky top-0 z-10 bg-background container, chips D7/D30/D90, aria-pressed, active/inactive class strings. page.tsx:64 defaults to 'D30'. |
| 3 | 4 summary cards stacked single-column (active users, total Graph hours, total Autotask hours, hours/active user) | VERIFIED | EngagementSummaryCard.tsx exists with text-2xl font-semibold big number + text-xs label. page.tsx:266-270 renders 4 instances in space-y-3. /api/mobile/engagement/summary returns all 4 totals from real DB queries. |
| 4 | Per-employee list renders sortable + searchable stacked rows (avatar/name/role/hours bar) with navigation link | VERIFIED | EngagementUserRow.tsx has Link to /mobile/engagement/${user.graphUserId}, avatar initials, text-sm font-semibold name, role conditional, h-1.5 bg-muted hours bar with bg-primary fill. EngagementSortChips.tsx + EngagementSearchInput.tsx wired in page. |
| 5 | Compact "hours trend" sparkline (no multi-series chart) renders at top of list, scoped to period | VERIFIED | EngagementHoursSparkline.tsx uses inline SVG only (no recharts), imports SparklinePoint from Plan 01 route, h-12 w-full SVG. /api/mobile/engagement/trend returns daily points via generate_series. Page passes points={trendPoints} period={period}. |
Score: 5/5 truths verified
Required Artifacts
| Artifact | Expected | Status | Details |
|---|---|---|---|
app/api/mobile/engagement/summary/route.ts |
Mobile summary endpoint (4 totals + configured flag) | VERIFIED | 152 lines. Exports MobileEngagementSummary, GET. requireAuth() first. Period whitelist + 400. Real DB queries (3 SQL queries). isMsgraphConfigured() called. No Zod. |
app/api/mobile/engagement/trend/route.ts |
Daily hours trend endpoint | VERIFIED | 92 lines. Exports SparklinePoint, EngagementTrendResponse, GET. requireAuth() first. generate_series for continuous daily series. Period whitelist + 400. No Zod. |
components/mobile/EngagementPeriodChips.tsx |
3-chip period selector | VERIFIED | 45 lines. 'use client'. Exports EngagementPeriodChips, EngagementPeriod, EngagementPeriodChipsProps. Sticky container, aria-pressed, active/inactive class strings. |
components/mobile/EngagementSummaryCard.tsx |
Single summary card primitive | VERIFIED | 25 lines. 'use client'. Exports EngagementSummaryCard. text-2xl font-semibold, text-xs text-muted-foreground, shadow-none. |
components/mobile/EngagementHoursSparkline.tsx |
Custom SVG sparkline | VERIFIED | 105 lines. 'use client'. Exports EngagementHoursSparkline. Inline SVG, stroke-primary, h-12 w-full, no recharts, SparklinePoint type from Plan 01. "No activity" fallback. |
components/mobile/EngagementSortChips.tsx |
3-chip sort selector | VERIFIED | 45 lines. 'use client'. Exports EngagementSortChips, EngagementSortKey (lowercase values). aria-pressed on each chip. |
components/mobile/EngagementSearchInput.tsx |
Debounced search input | VERIFIED | 49 lines. 'use client'. Exports EngagementSearchInput. 300ms debounce via setTimeout. aria-label, Search icon, shadcn Input. |
components/mobile/EngagementUserRow.tsx |
User row + getInitials | VERIFIED | 87 lines. 'use client'. Exports EngagementUserRow, getInitials, EngagementUserRowData, EngagementUserRowProps. Link to /mobile/engagement/${user.graphUserId}, hours bar, avatar initials, conditional role. |
components/mobile/EngagementUserRowSkeleton.tsx |
Skeleton matching row shape | VERIFIED | 23 lines. 'use client'. Exports EngagementUserRowSkeleton. Mirrors row: avatar circle, name, hours, role, bar. |
app/mobile/engagement/page.tsx |
Mobile engagement overview page | VERIFIED | 378 lines (well above 200 minimum). 'use client'. Default export MobileEngagementPage. All 7 Wave-2 components imported. All 3 endpoints called. IntersectionObserver. All states wired. |
Key Link Verification
| From | To | Via | Status | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|
summary/route.ts |
lib/auth-utils.ts |
requireAuth() first in handler |
WIRED | Line 23: const { error: authError } = await requireAuth() — occurs before any postgresClient.query call |
summary/route.ts |
lib/services/msgraph-factory.ts |
isMsgraphConfigured() |
WIRED | Line 4 import, called at lines 45 and 135 in response |
summary/route.ts |
engagement_snapshots / time_entries |
postgresClient.query |
WIRED | 3 SQL queries at lines 37, 71, 92, 117 against real tables |
trend/route.ts |
time_entries |
generate_series + LEFT JOIN |
WIRED | SQL query at line 45 uses time_entries with generate_series for continuous series |
EngagementHoursSparkline.tsx |
SparklinePoint type |
import type from '@/app/api/mobile/engagement/trend/route' |
WIRED | Line 10: import type { SparklinePoint } from '@/app/api/mobile/engagement/trend/route' |
EngagementUserRow.tsx |
/mobile/engagement/[graphUserId] |
next/link href template literal |
WIRED | Line 48: href={\/mobile/engagement/${user.graphUserId}`}` |
EngagementSummaryCard.tsx |
shadcn Card | @/components/ui/card |
WIRED | Line 9: import { Card, CardContent } from '@/components/ui/card' |
page.tsx |
/api/mobile/engagement/summary |
fetch in useCallback |
WIRED | Line 85: fetch(\/api/mobile/engagement/summary?period=${p}`)` |
page.tsx |
/api/mobile/engagement/trend |
fetch in useCallback |
WIRED | Line 100: fetch(\/api/mobile/engagement/trend?period=${p}`)` |
page.tsx |
/api/engagement/users |
fetch with period+sort+page params |
WIRED | Line 118: fetch(\/api/engagement/users?${sp.toString()}`)` |
page.tsx |
All 7 Engagement* components | named imports from @/components/mobile/Engagement* |
WIRED | Lines 16-22: 7 component imports, all rendered in JSX |
page.tsx |
MobileEngagementSummary type |
import type from '@/app/api/mobile/engagement/summary/route' |
WIRED | Line 14 |
Data-Flow Trace (Level 4)
| Artifact | Data Variable | Source | Produces Real Data | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
app/mobile/engagement/page.tsx |
summary |
fetch /api/mobile/engagement/summary → setSummary(data) |
Yes — 3 SQL queries against engagement_snapshots, graph_users, resources, time_entries |
FLOWING |
app/mobile/engagement/page.tsx |
trendPoints |
fetch /api/mobile/engagement/trend → setTrendPoints(data.points) |
Yes — generate_series + time_entries daily aggregate |
FLOWING |
app/mobile/engagement/page.tsx |
users |
fetch /api/engagement/users → setUsers(data.users) |
Yes — existing endpoint queries DB (reused as-is) | FLOWING |
EngagementHoursSparkline.tsx |
points prop |
Passed from page.tsx:285 as trendPoints |
Yes — flows from trend endpoint | FLOWING |
EngagementSummaryCard.tsx |
value, label props |
Passed from page.tsx:266-270 with formatted summary values |
Yes — flows from summary endpoint | FLOWING |
EngagementUserRow.tsx |
user, maxHours props |
Passed from page.tsx:335-346 per filteredUsers |
Yes — flows from users endpoint | FLOWING |
Behavioral Spot-Checks
Step 7b: SKIPPED — Next.js route handlers require a running server. All key behaviors were verified via static analysis of the fetch wiring, data transforms, and state management patterns.
Requirements Coverage
| Requirement | Source Plan | Description | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ENG-01 | 07-03 | /mobile/engagement overview page — real refactor, not desktop port |
SATISFIED | app/mobile/engagement/page.tsx, 378 lines, purpose-built phone-first (not ported from 1300-line desktop page) |
| ENG-02 | 07-02, 07-03 | Period selector chip row sticky just below page H1 | SATISFIED | EngagementPeriodChips.tsx (sticky strip). Deviation D-07: uses 7d/30d/90d instead of today/7d/30d — data layer constraint, documented and approved |
| ENG-03 | 07-01, 07-02, 07-03 | Summary cards stacked single-column (active users, Graph hours, AT hours, hours/user) | SATISFIED | All 4 cards via EngagementSummaryCard; totals from /api/mobile/engagement/summary |
| ENG-04 | 07-02, 07-03 | Per-employee list with sort control and search input | SATISFIED | EngagementUserRow, EngagementSortChips, EngagementSearchInput; sort chips wired to API; search debounced 300ms client-side |
| ENG-05 | 07-01, 07-02, 07-03 | Compact hours trend sparkline at top of list, scoped to period | SATISFIED | EngagementHoursSparkline (inline SVG, no recharts); /api/mobile/engagement/trend returns daily points via generate_series |
| ENG-09 | 07-03 | Engagement reachable from More drawer, NOT bottom bar | SATISFIED | MoreDrawer.tsx:37 has Engagement entry; BottomNav.tsx has 0 occurrences |
No orphaned requirements: REQUIREMENTS.md maps exactly ENG-01, ENG-02, ENG-03, ENG-04, ENG-05, ENG-09 to Phase 7. All 6 are accounted for across Plans 01/02/03.
Anti-Patterns Found
No anti-patterns detected. Scan covered all 10 Phase 7 files for TODO/FIXME/PLACEHOLDER comments, empty implementations, and hardcoded stub values. Zero matches found.
| File | Pattern | Severity | Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| (none) | — | — | — |
Human Verification Required
All 5 roadmap success criteria pass automated verification. The following items require human testing in a running browser environment:
1. Drawer-to-page navigation
Test: Open the app on a mobile viewport. Tap the "More" cell in the bottom nav. Tap "Engagement" in the Mobile sections row.
Expected: Navigation lands at /mobile/engagement inside the Phase 2 shell. Page renders H1 "Engagement", sticky 3-chip period selector, 4 summary card skeletons (then real values), sparkline skeleton (then chart), sort chips, search input, and employee row skeletons (then rows).
Why human: Drawer tap interaction, shell mounting, and initial loading state sequence require a running browser.
2. Period chip refetch behavior
Test: With data loaded, tap each of the three period chips (7d, 30d, 90d). Observe browser network panel.
Expected: Each tap fires exactly 3 requests (summary + trend + users). The active chip changes to bg-primary. All data updates.
Why human: Network request timing and visual active-state transitions require a running browser.
3. Sort chip single-fetch behavior
Test: Tap each sort chip. Observe network panel. Expected: Each sort chip tap fires exactly 1 request (users only). Summary and trend do NOT refetch. Why human: Requires distinguishing between fetch calls in a real browser.
4. Search debounce and no-matches state
Test: Type in the search input. Observe: (a) no fetch fires while typing; (b) list filters after 300ms pause; (c) if filter yields zero results, "No matches for ..." renders with "Clear search" button; (d) clearing the input restores the full list. Expected: Behavior as described. Client-side only. Why human: Debounce timing and filter state transitions require browser interaction with real data.
5. Sparkline visual rendering
Test: With data loaded, visually inspect the sparkline card. Expected: A thin primary-color line spanning the 48px SVG area. A faint baseline near the bottom. Label row: "Hours trend · last 30 days" (left) and "X.Xh today" or date-formatted value (right). No dots, axes, or tooltips. Why human: SVG path rendering and visual appearance require browser rendering.
6. Infinite scroll and Load more
Test: On a team with >50 staff, scroll to the bottom of the employee list. Expected: When the sentinel enters the viewport (200px before bottom), a new page loads automatically. The "Load more" button also works as a fallback. When the last page is reached, the button hides. Why human: Requires real paginated data and browser scroll observation.
7. User row navigation
Test: Tap a user row.
Expected: Browser navigates to /mobile/engagement/[graphUserId]. A 404 is expected (Phase 8 not built yet) — but the URL must contain the correct graphUserId, confirming the link is wired correctly.
Why human: Link navigation requires a browser.
Gaps Summary
No gaps. All automated checks pass:
- All 10 artifacts exist, are substantive (no stubs), and are fully wired
- All key links verified (auth gates, DB queries, component imports, fetch calls)
- Data flows from DB through API endpoints to page state to components
- TypeScript exits 0 (
npx tsc --noEmit --pretty) - Zero anti-patterns (no TODO/FIXME/placeholder/empty-implementation patterns)
- All 6 requirements (ENG-01..05, ENG-09) have implementation evidence
- Approved deviation D-07 (7d/30d/90d instead of today/7d/30d) is documented in CONTEXT.md — not a gap
Awaiting human verification of 7 behavioral/visual items above.
Inherited Issues (Not Counted Against Verdict)
Pre-existing test failures (2 tests in lib/services/analyzer/itglue-search.test.ts): These failures predate Phase 7. Phase 7 modified zero files in lib/services/analyzer/. Test suite otherwise passes 182/184 = 98.9%.
Inherited security gap (T-07-05/T-07-12): Existing /api/engagement/users endpoint lacks requireAuth(). Phase 7 reuses this endpoint as-is per D-16/D-34. Not made worse by this phase. Recommended for a future security phase.
Verified: 2026-05-04T12:00:00Z Verifier: Claude (gsd-verifier)