wulf-pulse/.planning/phases/08-engagement-user-profile-new/08-VERIFICATION.md

phase	verified	status	score	re_verification	human_verification
08-engagement-user-profile-new	2026-05-08T00:00:00Z	human_needed	12/13 must-haves verified	false	test expected why_human Navigate to /mobile/engagement, tap an employee row, press the device back button Returns to /mobile/engagement at the same scroll position as before tapping Scroll restoration (SC#2) is programmatic — the sessionStorage shim was added to app/mobile/engagement/page.tsx but the SUMMARY documents it as partially working. Browser-back scroll position cannot be verified by grep or static analysis. User has accepted the partial behavior as a known limitation.

Phase 8: Engagement User Profile (NEW) — Verification Report

Phase Goal: From the Engagement overview, a manager taps an employee row and arrives at a real, shareable profile page — single-column phone-first — and the device back gesture returns them to the overview. Verified: 2026-05-08 Status: human_needed Re-verification: No — initial verification

Goal Achievement

Observable Truths

#	Truth	Status	Evidence
1	Tapping a row in /mobile/engagement navigates to /mobile/engagement/{graphUserId}	✓ VERIFIED	EngagementUserRow.tsx:48 has href={'/mobile/engagement/${user.graphUserId}'} pointing to the real route at app/mobile/engagement/[userId]/page.tsx
2	The browser back gesture returns to the overview at the prior scroll position (SC#2)	? HUMAN NEEDED	sessionStorage shim exists at app/mobile/engagement/page.tsx:175-225 (rAF save + retry restore), but SUMMARY and context notes both document this as partial — does not reliably restore scroll. User accepted as known limitation.
3	The profile renders single-column in the specified order: H1 → period chips → identity header → 2×2 metric grid → activity breakdown → recent entries → recent meetings	✓ VERIFIED	page.tsx:183-224 confirms exact render order: <h1>, <EngagementPeriodChips>, <EngagementProfileHeader>, <EngagementProfileMetricGrid>, <EngagementProfileBreakdown>, <EngagementRecentEntries>, <EngagementRecentMeetings>
4	Identity header shows photo (or initials fallback), display name, jobTitle, department (omitted if null), email as mailto, last-active row when signal exists	✓ VERIFIED	EngagementProfileHeader.tsx:35-88 — photoFailed useState toggle, onError={() => setPhotoFailed(true)}, department conditional at line 78, href={mailto:${email}} at line 82, lastActiveLabel && at line 87
5	2×2 hero metric cards (Hours worked / Billable hours / Days worked / Meetings attended) render in grid-cols-2 from /api/engagement/user/[userId]?period=	✓ VERIFIED	EngagementProfileMetricGrid.tsx:24 has className="grid grid-cols-2 gap-3" with all four metric labels at lines 28, 34, 40, 46; data flows from page.tsx via props
6	Period chip selection refetches data; recent-items remain bound to 10 regardless of period	✓ VERIFIED	page.tsx:117 — useEffect deps [userId, period, retryNonce]; fetch at line 93 uses ?period=${period}; EngagementRecentEntries/Meetings components receive raw recentEntries / recentTeamsMeetings arrays not filtered by period
7	Activity breakdown renders Time / Communication / Meetings subsections with after-hours and Zoom conditional rows	✓ VERIFIED	EngagementProfileBreakdown.tsx:51-91 — three labeled <h3> subsections; showAfterHours at line 45 gates after-hours row; showZoom at line 46 gates Zoom row
8	Recent entries and meetings collapse/expand via shadcn Collapsible; Set state; period changes don't reset expansion	✓ VERIFIED	Both components use Collapsible, CollapsibleTrigger, CollapsibleContent from shadcn; useState<Set<string>>(new Set()) for expansion tracking; period changes propagate to page, not through the component state
9	404 from data endpoint renders inline "User not found" with back-to-Engagement link	✓ VERIFIED	page.tsx:120-132 — errorState === 'not-found' branch renders <h1>User not found</h1> and <Link href="/mobile/engagement">Back to Engagement</Link>
10	500/network failure renders sonner toast + inline Retry button via retryNonce increment	✓ VERIFIED	page.tsx:5 imports toast from 'sonner'; page.tsx:111 calls toast.error(); Retry button at line 143 calls setRetryNonce((n) => n + 1)
11	Photo endpoint non-200 silently falls back to initials — no toast, no error UI	✓ VERIFIED	EngagementProfileHeader.tsx:61 — onError={() => setPhotoFailed(true)} toggles the photoFailed state, rendering initials only; no toast import in that component
12	EngagementUserRow.tsx was NOT modified by this plan	✓ VERIFIED	git log components/mobile/EngagementUserRow.tsx — last commit is d637892 (Phase 7); no Phase 8 commits touch this file
13	/api/engagement/user/[userId]/route.ts was NOT modified by this plan	✓ VERIFIED	git log app/api/engagement/user/[userId]/route.ts — last commit is c518eef (unrelated); no Phase 8 commits touch this file

Score: 12/13 truths verified (1 requires human testing — SC#2 scroll restoration)

Required Artifacts

Artifact	Expected	Status	Details
lib/services/msgraph-client.ts	getUserPhotoBytes() method	✓ VERIFIED	Line 419 — async getUserPhotoBytes(userId) exists; returns ArrayBuffer on 2xx, null on 404, throws on other non-2xx; uses this.getToken()
app/api/mobile/engagement/user/[userId]/photo/route.ts	Photo proxy GET handler	✓ VERIFIED	67 lines; exports GET; requireAuth is first call (line 10); all status codes present (400, 404, 503)
app/mobile/engagement/[userId]/page.tsx	Mobile profile page	✓ VERIFIED	230 lines (>= 120 minimum); 'use client' at line 1; all 7 components wired
components/mobile/EngagementProfileSkeleton.tsx	Full-page skeleton	✓ VERIFIED	77 lines; exports EngagementProfileSkeleton; contains Skeleton
components/mobile/EngagementProfileHeader.tsx	Identity header card	✓ VERIFIED	94 lines; exports EngagementProfileHeader; photo + initials fallback wired
components/mobile/EngagementProfileMetricGrid.tsx	2×2 metric grid	✓ VERIFIED	51 lines; exports EngagementProfileMetricGrid; contains grid-cols-2
components/mobile/EngagementProfileBreakdown.tsx	Activity breakdown card	✓ VERIFIED	96 lines; exports EngagementProfileBreakdown; three subsections present
components/mobile/EngagementRecentEntries.tsx	Collapsible time entries list	✓ VERIFIED	103 lines; exports EngagementRecentEntries; Collapsible from shadcn; Number(entry.hours_worked).toFixed(1) coercion
components/mobile/EngagementRecentMeetings.tsx	Collapsible meetings list	✓ VERIFIED	142 lines; exports EngagementRecentMeetings; Collapsible from shadcn; Number(te.hours_worked).toFixed(1) coercion

Key Link Verification

From	To	Via	Status	Details
photo/route.ts	lib/services/msgraph-factory.ts	import { getMsgraphClient, isMsgraphConfigured }	✓ WIRED	Lines 3, 14, 39 — both functions imported and called
photo/route.ts	lib/auth-utils.ts	import { requireAuth }	✓ WIRED	Line 2 imports, line 10 calls requireAuth() as first handler action
photo/route.ts	MsGraphClient.getUserPhotoBytes	method call	✓ WIRED	Line 40 — client.getUserPhotoBytes(userId)
page.tsx	/api/engagement/user/[userId]	fetch in useEffect	✓ WIRED	Line 93 — fetch('/api/engagement/user/${userId}?period=${period}') in useEffect with deps [userId, period, retryNonce]
page.tsx	EngagementPeriodChips	import + JSX	✓ WIRED	Line 6 imports, lines 138 and 186 render <EngagementPeriodChips>
EngagementProfileHeader.tsx	/api/mobile/engagement/user/[userId]/photo	<img src={...}/photo}	✓ WIRED	Line 58 — src={'/api/mobile/engagement/user/${userId}/photo'}
EngagementProfileHeader.tsx	EngagementUserRow.tsx#getInitials	named import	✓ WIRED	Line 12 — import { getInitials } from '@/components/mobile/EngagementUserRow'; used at line 68

Data-Flow Trace (Level 4)

Artifact	Data Variable	Source	Produces Real Data	Status
page.tsx	data (ApiResponse)	/api/engagement/user/[userId] which queries graph_users, engagement_snapshots, time_entries, teams_meetings	Yes — route.ts lines 16-103 contain real SQL JOINs against Postgres tables	✓ FLOWING
EngagementProfileHeader.tsx	displayName, email, jobTitle, department, lastActiveAt	Props from page.tsx from data.user	Yes — sourced from DB graph_users table	✓ FLOWING
EngagementProfileMetricGrid.tsx	hoursWorked, billableHours, daysWorked, meetingsAttended	Props from page.tsx from data.hours	Yes — aggregated from time_entries + engagement_snapshots in the API	✓ FLOWING
EngagementRecentEntries.tsx	entries	Props from page.tsx from data.recentEntries	Yes — real time_entries rows from Postgres; NUMERIC coerced via Number(entry.hours_worked).toFixed(1)	✓ FLOWING
EngagementRecentMeetings.tsx	meetings	Props from page.tsx from data.recentTeamsMeetings	Yes — real teams_meetings rows with LEFT JOIN on attendees	✓ FLOWING

Behavioral Spot-Checks

Step 7b: SKIPPED — photo proxy requires live MSGRAPH credentials and cannot be exercised without a running server and Graph access. Page rendering requires browser.

Requirements Coverage

Requirement	Source Plan	Description	Status	Evidence
ENG-06	08-01, 08-02	User profile at /mobile/engagement/[userId], single-column layout: identity header → period selector → key metrics → activity breakdown → recent items	✓ SATISFIED	Real route at app/mobile/engagement/[userId]/page.tsx; render order confirmed; photo proxy powers avatar
ENG-07	08-02	User profile is a real page, not a modal — back gesture works	PARTIAL (human_needed)	Real Next.js App Router route confirmed (not a modal). Scroll position restore attempted via sessionStorage shim but only partially works — user accepted. The "real page, not a modal" portion is verified; the "back gesture at same scroll position" requires human testing.
ENG-08	08-02	Profile reuses existing engagement profile data endpoints; no new data	✓ SATISFIED	page.tsx:93 fetches /api/engagement/user/${userId}?period=${period} (existing endpoint); git log confirms the endpoint file was not modified by Phase 8

Anti-Patterns Found

File	Line	Pattern	Severity	Impact
(none)	—	—	—	No TODOs, FIXMEs, placeholders, or empty implementations found in any Phase 8 file

Human Verification Required

1. Scroll Restoration on Browser Back Gesture (SC#2)

Test: Open /mobile/engagement on a mobile device or narrow browser viewport. Scroll the employee list down past 3-4 rows. Tap one row to navigate to the profile. Then press the browser back button (or swipe-back on iOS/Android). Expected: The overview page scrolls back to the same position — the same row that was tapped is visible without manual re-scrolling. Why human: The sessionStorage shim (app/mobile/engagement/page.tsx:175-225) saves window.scrollY and main.scrollTop on navigation, then attempts restore via requestAnimationFrame retry on mount. Whether this reliably restores scroll depends on browser, Next.js App Router behavior, and the shell's overflow-y-auto vs window.scroll interaction. Per the SUMMARY and context notes, the implementation was attempted but user testing confirmed it does not consistently restore scroll. The user has accepted this as a known limitation. Verify the current behavior matches the acceptance (partial — page scrolls back to top, not prior position) and confirm no regression was introduced.

Gaps Summary

No blocking gaps. All code artifacts exist, are substantive, and are wired to real data sources. The only open item (SC#2 scroll restoration) was user-tested during Phase 8 execution and accepted as a known limitation. It does not prevent the core goal ("manager taps a row, arrives at a real profile page") from being met — it is a UX polish concern on the return journey.

The human_needed status reflects that SC#2 needs to be acknowledged by the reviewer rather than re-verified mechanically.

---

Verified: 2026-05-08 Verifier: Claude (gsd-verifier)